First, check if it's the same job
A quote often looks high because it includes more. Before you decide, compare these against your other quotes:
- Plant size. Bigger containers cost more and fill in sooner.
- Plant count. Closer spacing means more plants.
- Extras. Haul-off, soil prep, irrigation and a longer warranty all add up.
Then, check if it's really high
Ask the other contractors to price the missing items. If the high quote is still well above the others for the same plants, sizes and extras, it's high. If the gap closes, it was the only complete quote.
Check the plant count yourself. Enter the bed size and spacing in the free plant calculator. If a quote has far more plants than the bed needs, ask why.
An example
A homeowner gets two quotes to replant a front bed. Example numbers, for illustration:
| Quote 1 | Quote 2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $6,200 | $8,900 |
| Shrub size | 3-gallon | 7-gallon |
| Haul-off | Not mentioned | Included |
| Drip irrigation | "By others" | Included |
| Warranty | 90 days | 1 year |
Quote 2 looked $2,700 high. Once Quote 1 was priced with the same shrub size, haul-off and drip, the gap was a few hundred dollars, and Quote 2 had the longer warranty. It wasn't too high. It was the only complete quote.
Other things that raise a price
- Access. A backyard with no truck access means more hand work.
- What comes out. Big shrubs, stumps and old rock take time to remove.
- Soil. Hard or poor soil may need amending before planting.
- Small jobs. Many contractors have a minimum, so a tiny job can look pricey.
- Timing. A rush job, or the busy spring season, can cost more.
When paying more is worth it
A higher quote can be the better deal when it includes a longer warranty, larger plants that fill in sooner, irrigation that actually waters the new plants, and a contractor with insurance and any license your area requires. Those are the things that save you money a year from now.
How to ask about a high quote
Most contractors are glad to explain. Their answer often shows you what the cheaper quotes left out.
